I’ve finally compiled my top 5 TV dramas! Remember, for a self-professed TV shut-in, picking these was a harder decision for me than Meryl Streep had in
Sophie’s Choice.
5.
Gossip Girl (The CW) As a dramedy that satirizes the shameless rich and voyeuristic poor (AKA us!) equally,
Gossip Girl recognizes the exploits of a few Upper East Side 17-year-olds and their 24-year-old parents as outlandish (their maximalist wardrobes are just as hyperbolic as their personalities—Chuck Bass, I’m talking about you!) but its website-within-a-show concept ingeniously throws the consumerist blame back on us, the audience, the main culprit in this
TMZ/Perez Hilton/
Us Weekly world where we’re all perpetually trying to move on up to that deluxe apartment (with a Central Park view) in the sky. In a brilliant scene from season one, blue-blooded Blair daunts the bourgeois (and ridiculously underage) Jenny with a martini. Jenny attempts to save face by claiming she doesn’t like vodka. “Well that’s nice, because this is gin, as it should be,” Blair snaps back. “Either swallow that, or swipe your MetroCard back home.” No other rich-kid soap (and there have been thousands) so vividly evokes the great divide of old money versus new money—gin versus vodka—with such cruel yet stylized panache. (Season 2 currently airing)
4.
Friday Night Lights (NBC/The 101) While we hate this show right now for signing a deal with DirecTV to air its third season on a satellite channel no one has (it’ll run on NBC later), we have to rate
FNL slightly above
Gossip Girl just because I’m pretty sure it’s the first teen show ever to not only be set somewhere outside of New York or LA (ew!), but to actually feature small-town, low-income kids (gross!) who don’t wear haute couture to homeroom (oh, the horror!) and don’t look like they just fell out of an Abercrombie & Fitch catalog. (Actually, aside from
Landry, they’re all pretty gorgeous.) Tim Riggins’s white trash brother Billy said it best in the first few minutes of the pilot: “This is real life, not
Maxim magazine.” Not that we’re decrying the world of
Gossip Girl in which it’s feasible for a 16-year-old to own and operate a burlesque club, instead we’re celebrating these two, opposing portrayals of fantasy and reality, the latter of which
FNL does to a T. (Season 3 currently airing on The 101, will air on NBC in 2009)
3.
Dexter (Showtime) Throwing the audience’s sympathies on the side of a murderer is nothing new. Hitchcock did it decades ago. But being able to keep your audience in a constant state of Hitchcockian suspense every minute of every episode of a 12-part, hour-long series that’s now in its third season sure is. In this TV landscape, where we’re plagued with 8
CSIs, 12
Law & Orders, and countless other inane, basic cable cop shows,
Dexter brilliantly subverts the done-to-death cops-versus-bad guys formula by combining cop and bad guy into one with our titular hero/villain—a forensics specialist who moonlights as a vigilante serial killer. Jennifer Carpenter as Dexter’s adoptive sister Debra is our absolute favorite bad-ass, post-post-feminist cop who could wipe the floor with that whiny southern belle from
The Closer! (Season 3 currently airing).
2.
Skins (E4/BBC America) It’s just occurred to me that this is the third show on my list about teenagers and how, perhaps, as someone who hasn’t been a teen for 4 years, I should consider watching more adult-oriented shows. But why would I do that when I can watch these Bristolian badasses engage in shocking levels of substance abuse, pan-sexual intercourse, and everything else American TV kids can’t do because of the pesky FCC? But to say this show is just about sex, drugs, and bad, European techno music would be to completely ignore its incredible heart. The
Skins characters aren’t your typical disaffected youth—rather they’re extremely affected by parents who have failed them and teachers who (in Chris’s case) sleep with them. (Season 2 currently airing on BBC America, Season 3 starts on E4 in 2009)
1.
Mad Men (AMC) I know, I know,
Mad Men is topping every list these days. It’s just as much of a cliché now to refer to it as the greatest show on TV as it was to say the same about
The Sopranos for the better part of this decade. But there never was a show more deserving of the abdicated throne of that title than this one—
Mad Men’s creator Matthew Weiner actually wrote 12 episodes of
The Sopranos. The genius of
MM lies in its ability to subtlety yet effectively comment on basically every important aspect of American culture and how it has changed (or hasn’t changed) in the second half of the twentieth century; family values, capitalism, religion, women’s rights, civil rights, class stratification, politics, and more are discussed via the concept of the advertiser marketing values to the masses. We as viewers are left to wonder how authentic the American identity actually is if so many of our thoughts and opinions are shaped by men in suits smoking cigarettes and munching sandwiches planning out exactly how we’re going to feel about all these issues.
Mad Men asks us, Is America just one big commercial? Discuss! (Season 3 starts in 2009)
Honorable mention:
Breaking Bad (AMC),
Big Love (HBO),
Lost (ABC)
Dishonorable mention:
24 (FOX) Season six—also known as the season during which even the die-hard fans stopped watching—was apparently (yeah, I was one of those who ditched!) so bad that even the writers apologized for it and promised to do better next time. After completely sitting out 2008 because of the writer’s strike,
24 will be back this Sunday with a 2-hour TV movie (
24: Redemption) that eschews the trademark countdown clock and fills us in on what Jack has been up to lately. (Plus, Jack will be in Africa meaning we might get to see him go toe-to-toe with an angry gazelle!) Then a new and (hopefully) improved season 7 will start in January.